So, party control explains little. Yet the election calendar itself does seem to influence market behaviour, even if the winner doesn’t. Midterm years can often be choppy through late summer and early autumn, before a rally once the result is known.
Since the Second World War, the S&P 500 has been higher 12 months after every midterm election. And there’s no denying there has been a degree of chop in the run-up to this year’s vote.
But this is necessarily a small sample. The simplest explanation for the pattern, if it really exists, is that there’s always uncertainty ahead of an election, and investors tend to react positively once it clears.
Any historic pattern shouldn’t be used as a trading strategy on its own. That’s especially true now. The global economy is dealing with two major wars: the conflict with Iran, which has disrupted Middle East oil supplies and kept Brent crude above $100 a barrel, and the ongoing war in Ukraine. Add to that a borrowing boom to fund the build-out of AI infrastructure, uncertainty over inflation and interest rates, and now a wave of civil unrest across Europe, with cost-of-living and student protests spreading from France to Italy, Spain, Portugal and Albania.